Alaric assigns the students community service as punishment for the fight that broke out after the game, which Lizzie blames Josie and Alaric for. Hope is also there for using black magic, and starts to bond with Josie.
A new monster is posing as a school councilor; a sprite, with the ability to make make everyone believe that he’s always been there. He convinces Landon to put on a musical about Elena, Caroline, Stefan, Damon, and the founding of the school.