In Alison’s biology notebook, Emily, Aria, and Hanna discover a conversation between Alison and a friend where Alison talks about a “beach hottie.” Emily turns to CeCe for answers about the beach hottie but CeCe claims Ali never told her who it was.
Emily seeks Dr. Sullivan to help her deal with confounding emotions over killing someone in self-defense. Dr. Sullivan suggests hypnotherapy, which results in confusing Emily further.
Spencer continues on a downward spiral from her break-up with Toby. Andrew Campbell kicks Spencer off the scholastic decathlon. Emily tries to talk to Spencer but Spencer refuses.
The hunt is on for discovering the identity of the girl in the red coat. Hanna comes clean to Ashley about knowing CeCe and that she and her friends found out about an illicit relationship between Ali and Wilden.
Spencer reveals to Aria and Emily that Toby is helping Mona. Aria returns to Ezra’s apartment to find he has returned…with Maggie and Malcolm. Emily and Hanna arrive at Toby’s apartment and find a parking pass with the name “E. Lamb,” Toby’s alias for Radley
Hanna and Ashley are blindsided when Detective Wilden approaches them at the church where they are meeting Ted for coffee. Emily is surprised when Shana invites her to coffee, only to introduce her to Olympic gold medalist Missy Franklin.
Spencer discovers a map of Radley that Mona created on a board game. Ella warns Hanna that Jamie may have traded the bell from the church for a new one of much lesser value.
